Sunday, September 21, 2014

Helmets in Women’s Lacrosse: A No-brainer?

Recently while flipping through my “Lacrosse Magazine” I came across an article about whether or not women’s lacrosse players should be required to wear helmets. It is currently a hot debate in the women’s lacrosse community. I believe that commanding women to wear helmets in lacrosse would be an absurd and unnecessary regulation.

Currently women lacrosse players are required to wear goggles that protect your eyes (picture below). Although most every state abides by this rule there is an exception. Florida High School Lacrosse Association has mandated that helmets be worn by all women lacrosse players beginning in the 2015 season. Roger Dearing, FHSAA executive director says it, "Adds a layer of protection for the girls." Their reasoning behind the jurassic shift  is that it is an additional preventative measure to help reduce concussion and other head injury rates.

Screen Shot 2014-09-21 at 7.17.23 PM.pngScreen Shot 2014-09-21 at 7.18.22 PM.png


While a helmet is undoubtedly another layer of protection I would argue that it is not the right kind of protection. Helmets blunt the actual collision but the brain still hits against the inside of the skull, which is what causes a concussion.


Additionally I believe that with the addition of helmets, play becomes much more rough. Right now when I play lacrosse I am careful of hitting another players stick when it is close to their heads but when you add a helmet to the equation I think that people will justify their violent actions on the field because the other player is wearing a helmet.

If Florida and other states are truly concerned for their players well-being they should consider taking a deeper look at the referees instead of head gear. They officiate the game and can control the nature of it much more than any helmet could. The referees dictate the type of play that is allowed so it is key that they have a firm knowledge of the game and call teams out when they see dangerous play.

Do you think helmets are the right precautionary measure for keeping women's lacrosse safe?

2 comments:

  1. Hi Clare! This post has much potential -- I had no idea this was a controversy. But it seems a bit narrow in focus -- what is the American theme, exactly? Where is the analysis of the quote from Dearing? I think it's very telling that you refer to players as "women" and he refers to them as "girls".

    ReplyDelete
  2. I read your blog and after read you blog I feel that your blog is worth for us. Thank you for sharing it. Looking forward to see more worth blogs in future.

    lacross helmets

    ReplyDelete